Property Management Blog


Your Guide to Landlord Insurance for San Diego Home Rentals

Your Guide to Landlord Insurance for San Diego Home Rentals

Renting out your San Diego home can provide excellent passive income. However, being a landlord comes with risks beyond daily wear and tear. One major storm or accident could leave your property damaged and your bank account drained if you’re not properly insured.

That’s where landlord insurance comes in. While you may already have homeowners insurance, this doesn’t fully cover you when tenants occupy your property. Read on for a comprehensive look at how landlord insurance works, what it covers, and tips for San Diego homeowners renting out their prized real estate.

What Is Landlord Insurance?

Landlord insurance, sometimes called rental property insurance, protects home or building owners who rent out their property to tenants. It provides financial protection if:

  • The rental property suffers damage from events like fires, storms, or vandalism.
  • Someone gets injured on the rental premises and files a liability lawsuit.
  • A catastrophic event renders the property uninhabitable, leading to lost rental income.

Landlord policies contain provisions that regular homeowners insurance doesn’t. Without the right policy, you could be left covering expensive repairs and legal fees out-of-pocket after an incident at your rental.

Why Landlord Insurance Matters in San Diego

San Diego’s desirable beachside locale and near-perfect weather make it a top destination for renters. As a homeowner, you can capitalize on high demand and seasonal tourism by renting out your property short or long-term. But paradise always comes with a few risks.

Natural Disasters

While idyllic most days, San Diego’s coastal position also makes it vulnerable to natural disaster risks like flooding, earthquakes, wildfires, and more. Landlord insurance prepares you for damage and lost income when disaster strikes.

Tenant Turnover

Frequent tenant turnover from short-term vacation rentals can lead to accelerated property wear. The constant inflow of new tenants may overlook maintenance issues a long-term renter would notice and report.

Renter Population

Over half of San Diegans rent their homes. More tenants mean more potential for liability claims if someone gets injured on your property.

Proper landlord insurance gives you a financial safety net when managing these inherent risks of renting out property in America’s Finest City.

What Does Landlord Insurance Cover?

Standard landlord insurance contains three main coverage components:

Property damage coverage

This covers repair costs if the rental property's structure or contents are damaged. Covered perils typically include:

  • Fire or smoke damage
  • Theft
  • Vandalism
  • Windstorms
  • Hail or lightning
  • Water damage from flooding or plumbing issues
  • Falling objects like trees
  • Vehicle or aircraft crashes into the building

Coverage limits depend on factors like location, value of the dwelling, and amount of personal contents made available to tenants. Work with your insurer to set appropriate limits.

Liability coverage

Liability insurance covers costly accidents that happen on your property. If a tenant or guest is injured and decides to sue, liability coverage helps pay for legal defense fees and any settlements awarded to the plaintiff.

For severe incidents, liability payouts can easily climb into the millions. Don’t skimp on liability protection.

Loss of rents coverage

If covered property damage renders your rental uninhabitable for a period, loss of rents coverage reimburses you for the rental income lost during repairs.

For San Diego landlords dependent on steady rental revenue, this coverage is hugely beneficial. It provides cash flow stability when you can’t rent out your damaged property.

What’s Not Covered by Landlord Insurance?

While landlord policies are robust, some things may fall outside your coverage:

  • Tenant belongings - Policies cover the structure and landlord's personal property only, not tenants' possessions. Tenants need renters insurance for their own items.
  • Wear and tear - Gradual damage from ordinary use isn't covered. Ensure tenants understand their duty to avoid negligence.
  • Intentional landlord damages - Intentional damage or neglect of the property by the landlord voids coverage.

Tips for Optimizing Your San Diego Landlord Policy

With the right landlord insurance partner, you can craft a policy tailored to your specific needs and budget. Here are tips for customizing your coverage:

Compare quotes - Rates vary widely among insurers. Shop around for the best price from highly-rated carriers.

Meet local requirements - Some mortgage lenders require landlord insurance. Check city regulations too.

Mind the deductible - Choosing a higher deductible reduces your premiums but increases out-of-pocket costs per claim. Find the right balance.

Bolster liability protection - Legal claims are expensive. Don’t skimp on liability if it puts your assets at risk.

Add loss of rents - Without this coverage, you lose income if the property is unrentable. It's usually affordable and worth including.

Require tenant insurance - Ask tenants to carry renters insurance so their possessions and liability are covered.

Inspect annually - Schedule annual walkthroughs with your insurer to identify issues before they become claims.

Create an emergency plan - Have protocols in place to mitigate damage, communicate with tenants, and quickly file claims after disasters.

With smart planning, you can safeguard your San Diego rental with the right landlord insurance. Work with a reputable agent to structure the optimal policy and exclusions.

Finding the Best Rate of Renters Insurance

Whether you’re insuring a single-family rental property or an entire apartment building, San Diego landlords should access coverage that’s:

  • Affordable - Compare quotes from major carriers to find the lowest price.
  • Reliable - Insure with reputable national and regional insurance companies.
  • Flexible - Customize your policy limits and coverage options.
  • Local - Licensed San Diego agents provide personalized guidance.
  • Convenient - Quote and buy landlord insurance entirely online.

Furthermore, when landlords require renters' insurance from their tenants, it streamlines coordination and provides vital protection for occupants and their possessions.

Frequently Asked Questions About San Diego Landlord Insurance

Is landlord insurance required in San Diego?

California state law doesn’t mandate landlord insurance. However, your mortgage lender may require coverage if you have a loan on the property. Landlord insurance is highly recommended to protect your rental investment.

How much is landlord insurance in San Diego?

Average landlord insurance costs in San Diego range from $700 to $2,500 annually based on factors like location, claims history, and amount of coverage. Expect to pay around 25% more compared to a standard San Diego homeowners policy.

What does loss of rents coverage cost?

Loss of rents coverage often adds 10% or less to your total policy premium. Given San Diego's exposure to disasters, this affordable coverage provides invaluable financial protection when you can't rent due to property damage.

Can I bundle landlord insurance with homeowners or auto policies?

While bundling home and auto policies yields discounts, landlord policies need to be separate. Some insurers offer multi-policy discounts if you have other insurance with them already. Ask your agent about available bundles and discounts.

What liability limit should I carry?

Experts recommend at least $500,000 in liability coverage and more if possible. Liability payouts can exceed policy limits, leaving you responsible for the balance. Umbrella insurance also provides an extra liability buffer.

What qualifies tenants for a policy discount?

Requiring tenants to carry renters insurance may qualify your property for a multi-policy discount. Deductibles, safety features like alarms and sprinklers, and tenant tenure over 12 months may also reduce rates.


If you're a client of Harland Property Management, rest assured that our services include providing excellent guidance on securing the right landlord insurance. Our team is dedicated to assisting our clients in navigating insurance matters, in addition to expertly handling day-to-day rental operations through our property management services. We understand that managing your own rental property in San Diego can be challenging, which is why we offer flexible, cost-effective services tailored to your specific rental property needs. If you're seeking stress-free and profitable rental property ownership, we're here to help. Contact us today to discuss how we can assist you with insurance guidance and simplify the management of your local rental investment property.